MIME-Version: 1.0 X-Document-Type: Worksheet Content-Location: file:///C:/50430E49/ReadAPI.htm Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/html; charset="us-ascii"
ID Type Change To Category Severity Change To Summary Pro= posal  Note Editor
593 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.12 Routines should = be in table format Editor should centraliz= e all routines in VPI chapter (move out from this chapter) Y
587 Errata SV-CC text 31.8.7 Please replace = the term "user" with a more accurate term. Close Duplicate of 572 Y
588 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.9 uses the term "user", and has grammatically incorrect sentences Close Duplicate of 572 Y
583 Clarification SV-CC minor text 31.8.4.2 terminology f= irst defined in a footnote? Strike out footnote (no= t sure why not edited out before) -- "trace" is used already in Assertion chapter, no need to clarify. Y
567 Errata Clarification SV-CC major minor 31.7 arbitrary overloa= ding of the routines Close This mimics VHPI vhpi_c= reate. Idea is to minimize routines.
579 Errata SV-CC major text 31.8.3.2 This section = should be replaced with a object model diagram Keep the example (reque= sted by users when added) -- can possibly move to an Annex if desired. The section is describi= ng application code -- the basic OMDs are in chapter and should be moved to = VPI like we did for the other API (assertion). Ditto for the remaining API (coverage). Y
573 Enhancement Clarification SV-CC major minor 31 superfluous functio= nality added in the name of performance Close This is an enhancement.= Not clear what is desired to be omitted from functionality but from additional requirements posted seems the "extra functionality" need only be clarified.
570 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.8.1 Need prototype = for vpi_load_extension() Posted (Abi) Editor can handle like = 593 Y
571 Errata SV-CC minor 31.8.1 unnecessary com= plication added for vpi_close() Posted (Abi) Proposal seems ok
561 Errata SV-CC minor 31.4.2 vpi_free_object= () should be explicitly referenced here Posted (Abi) Proposal seems ok
572 Errata SV-CC minor 31.8 make use of the t= erm 'user' Posted (Abi) Editor should handle th= is (along with rest of LRM) Y
560 Errata Clarification SV-CC major text 31.4.1 & 31.4.2.1 Overloading vpi_handle() is a bad idea Reword to say: the rout= ine vpi_handle() when called with a vpiTrvsObj vpiType returns a value change traverse handle.
559 Errata Clarification SV-CC minor 31.4.2 Only need one c= ollection type Close The *vpiType* of a coll= ection handle can be vpiCollection, vpiObjCollection, or vpiTrvsCollection. This approaches leaves one generic type, and 2 specialized ones -- this architecture is meant to be clearer. Also a mimic of VHPI, see http://www.eda.org/sv-cc/hm/1573.html
592 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.12 return values for functions is backwards Ask Editor to handle re= turn value flip as part of 593 Y
590 Errata SV-CC major 31.10 Should provide d= lopen() like functionality dlopen was discussed be= fore -- should review the reasoning behind current approach. Not Immediate
584 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.8.4.2 implies that = vpi_goto() creates new handle Strike out the misleadi= ng text ("new").
581 Clarification SV-CC minor text 31.8.4.1 Need to clari= fy the first paragraph Can choose to move exam= ples to an Annex if desired. A usage example
580 Errata Clarification SV-CC minor 31.8.4 section is not = necessary and colloquial Can choose to move exam= ples to an Annex if desired. Another usage example
568 Clarification Clarification SV-CC major minor 31.8.1 initialization = and loading functionality is optional? Close Clarify the usage of initialization
565 Errata SV-CC minor 31.6 remove first para= graph of this section Remove paragraph like w= e did for Assertion API
563 Errata SV-CC minor 31.5 diagram in figure= 31-18 needs to be redrawn Diagram needs update --= unnamed classes (also drawn with the name field (blank) for some reason) have no = need (check with Francoise for history of this, also get the fm probably on reflector still).
562 Errata Clarification SV-CC minor 31.5 needless restrict= ion on traverse object creation - poor terminology Close Bullet just says object= must have a value, clarify.
558 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.3.3 rename section = to "Access availability" Change section name Y
557 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.3.1 specific refere= nces to objects should be removed Remove paragraph like w= e did for Assertion API We did same for asserti= on -- should be integrated into VPI clause proper Y
556 Errata SV-CC major text 31.2 Beginning of this= section not needed in larger context of spec Close Motivation for need/usa= ge is warranted Y
555 Errata SV-CC major text 31.1 Introduction not = needed in context of the larger document Close Motivation for need/usa= ge is warranted Y
589 Errata SV-CC minor text 31.10 cannot set the u= ser_data field Close Duplicate of 572 Y